If you’re reading this, there’s a really good chance you start your day with one of two drinks – coffee or tea. 

Maybe it’s the aroma of freshly ground coffee brewing or the peaceful minutes of waiting while your tea steeps.  Perhaps you have a mug in both worlds with coffee in the morning and tea in the afternoon.

Coffee and tea are two of the most popular drinks in the world, and they actually have quite a bit in common. Both come from plants. Both can have caffeine. Both have naturally occurring plant compounds. And both have become part of daily routines and cultures around the world.

But there are also some big differences.

Coffee and tea come from different plants, are processed differently, taste different, brew differently, and usually contain different amounts of caffeine.

So, grab your favorite mug. Let's break down coffee and tea to find what they have in common and where they differ.

Looking for something to fill that mug? Explore our Organic, Fairtrade coffees, small-batch roasted to bring out the natural flavor already inside the bean.

Coffee and Tea: The Quick Comparison

Before we dig deeper, here is the simple version.

Coffee	Tea
Made from roasted coffee seeds, commonly called beans	Traditional tea is made from tea leaves
Usually higher in caffeine	Usually lower in caffeine
Often bold, rich, fruity, nutty, or chocolatey	Often light, earthy, floral, grassy, or tannic
Commonly brewed for a few minutes	Often steeped for several minutes
Many flavors depend on origin, processing, roast, and brewing	Many flavors depend on tea type, origin, oxidation, and brewing
Can be served hot or cold	Can be served hot or cold

Neither one has to be the winner.

The better question is: What are you looking for in your cup?

Where Do Coffee and Tea Come From?

One of the biggest differences between coffee and tea starts at the plant.

Coffee Comes from a Fruit

Coffee beans are not technically beans.

They are seeds found inside the fruit of the coffee plant. These fruits are often called coffee cherries because of their round shape and red color when ripe.

After the coffee cherries are harvested, the seeds are separated from the fruit, processed, dried, sorted, shipped, roasted, ground, and finally brewed.

That is quite a journey before your morning cup ever reaches the kitchen table (check out how far our Rwanda beans travel before they get to your mug).

Where coffee is grown also matters. Soil, elevation, climate, coffee variety, farming methods, and processing can all affect flavor.

That is why a coffee from Ethiopia may taste very different from a coffee grown in Peru, Colombia, or Mexico.

At Philly Fair Trade Roasters, we love that part of coffee. Each origin has a story, and good roasting helps those natural characteristics shine.

No artificial flavors needed or added.

Tea Comes from Leaves

Traditional teas such as black tea, green tea, white tea, and oolong tea come from the leaves of the tea plant.

The major differences between those teas come largely from how the leaves are picked and processed.

Green tea receives less oxidation, helping preserve its fresh, grassy character. Black tea is more fully oxidized, creating deeper color and stronger flavors. Oolong generally falls somewhere between the two.

Herbal teas are a little different.

Drinks such as peppermint, chamomile, and rooibos are often called tea, but they do not come from the traditional tea plant. They are infusions made from other herbs, flowers, roots, or plants.  Herbal teas are typically caffeine free.

Do Coffee and Tea Both Have Caffeine?

Yes, although the amount is usually quite different.

For many people, caffeine is one of the biggest factors in the coffee vs tea decision.

According to the FDA, an 8-ounce cup of coffee generally contains about 80 to 100 milligrams of caffeine, while an 8-ounce cup of green or black tea generally contains about 30 to 50 milligrams. The exact amount varies based on the product and how it is prepared.

That means coffee generally gives you more caffeine per cup.

For someone starting an early morning, heading to work, getting kids ready for school, or trying to focus on a project, that extra caffeine may be exactly what they want.

Tea can provide caffeine too, but often in a smaller amount.

What About Decaf Coffee?

Decaf does not always mean completely caffeine-free.

The FDA notes that an 8-ounce cup of decaf coffee typically still has a small amount of caffeine, often around 2 to 15 milligrams.

That can make decaf a useful choice for people who love the flavor and ritual of coffee but want to cut back on caffeine.

Caffeine affects everyone differently, so your ideal amount may be very different from someone else's.

Likewise, herbal teas often have no caffeine, just check your specific herbal tea to make sure!

How Do Coffee and Tea Taste Different?

Here is where things get fun.

Both coffee and tea can offer a huge range of flavors.

Coffee Flavor

Coffee can naturally remind you of:

• Chocolate
• Caramel
• Nuts
• Berries
• Citrus
• Stone fruit
• Honey
• Spices
• Flowers

Those flavors can come from the coffee's origin, variety, growing conditions, processing, roasting, and brewing.

When you see tasting notes like dark chocolate, cherry, berry, or toasted nuts on a coffee bag, it does not mean those flavors were added.

They are natural flavor characteristics that can develop in the coffee and brought out through the roasting process.

That is an important part of how we approach roasting at Philly Fair Trade Roasters. We want good coffee to taste like good coffee.

Real beans. Thoughtfully sourced. Roasted with care.  Nothing artificial. 

Tea Flavor

Tea has its own wide range of flavors.

Depending on the type, tea may taste:

• Floral
• Grassy
• Earthy
• Sweet
• Fruity
• Malty
• Smoky
• Spicy

A light green tea may taste delicate and fresh, while a strong black tea may have a deeper and richer character.

Just like coffee, small changes in growing, processing, water temperature, and brewing time can change the final cup.

Coffee vs Tea: Which Is Stronger?

This question can mean two different things.

If you mean caffeine, coffee generally wins.

If you mean flavor, there is no simple answer.

A dark, full-bodied cup of coffee may taste much stronger than green tea. But a heavily brewed black tea can also have a powerful flavor.

And a light-roast coffee can be bright, fruity, and delicate rather than heavy or bitter.

Keeping in mind that dark coffee does not mean ‘strong’ coffee or a light roast mean ‘weak coffee.’  Brewing ratios and roast level are two different things. 

Health Benefits of Coffee and Tea

Coffee and tea both have naturally occurring plant compounds, including polyphenols.

Harvard's Nutrition Source notes that coffee has compounds such as chlorogenic acid, while tea has different polyphenols, including catechins and theaflavins. Research has linked regular consumption of both drinks with a variety of possible health benefits, although health outcomes depend on many factors and research continues to develop.

The big takeaway?

You do not necessarily need to choose coffee or tea based on which one has been declared "healthier."

Both can fit into a healthy lifestyle for many people.

What you add to them matters too.

A simple cup of black coffee and a dessert drink in a mug with coffee added are two very different beverages. The same is true for unsweetened tea compared with bottled tea loaded with added sugar.

Harvard describes plain coffee and tea as low-calorie beverage choices that have beneficial plant compounds.

Keep it simple, enjoy what you like, and pay attention to how your body responds.

Coffee and Tea Are Both Daily Rituals

There is another similarity that nutrition labels cannot measure very well.

Ritual.

Coffee and tea both create a reason to slow down.

Maybe you grind your coffee while the house is still quiet.

Maybe you make tea every afternoon and step away from your screen for ten minutes.

Maybe your mug comes with you on the drive to work every single morning.

The drink matters.

But so does the moment around it.

Coffee is more than caffeine for a lot of us. It is part of how the day begins.

That first smell.

That warm mug.

That first sip.

Sometimes the simplest routines are the ones we look forward to most.

It's a good day to have a good day—and a good cup certainly doesn't hurt.

How Brewing Coffee and Tea Is Different

Another major difference between coffee and tea is how we prepare them.

Tea is usually made by placing leaves in hot water and allowing them to steep.

Coffee brewing is a little different because water needs to move through or interact with ground coffee to pull out the flavors we want.

Common coffee methods include:

• Automatic drip
• Pour-over
• French press
• Espresso
• AeroPress
• Cold brew

No matter which method you use, a few basics make a big difference.

Fresh coffee helps.

The right grind helps.

And good water really helps.

Because most of your brewed coffee is water, poor-tasting water can quickly turn great beans into a disappointing cup.  Try using filtered water for brewing, avoiding distilled water which often results in a ‘flat’ taste.  Quick tip – if water doesn’t taste good on its own, the coffee (or tea) you make with it likely won’t taste good either. 

Recommended internal link: Read our guide to Filtered Water for Coffee for one of the simplest ways to improve your brew at home.

Does Coffee Require More Work Than Tea?

It can—but it doesn't have to.

Coffee sometimes gets made to sound complicated.

You need a certain grinder.

Then a scale.

Then the perfect kettle.

Then somebody starts talking about extraction percentages and suddenly making breakfast feels like a chemistry class.

We think great coffee should be easier than that.

Start with good beans.

Use fresh water (filtered if possible)

Use the right grind for your brewer.

Measure your coffee consistently.

Adjust based on what tastes good to you.

That's enough to make a noticeable difference.

You do not have to become a coffee expert to make excellent coffee at home.

What Coffee and Tea Have in Common

With all the talk about tea vs coffee, it is easy to focus only on the differences.

But their similarities may be even more interesting.

Both drinks:

• Come from agricultural crops
• Reflect the places where they are grown
• Can have caffeine
• Contain naturally occurring plant compounds
• Can be served hot or cold
• Are affected by water quality
• Can have complex natural flavors
• Are part of traditions around the world
• Depend on the work of farmers

That last point matters.

Before coffee reaches your brewer or tea reaches your kettle, real people planted, cared for, harvested, and processed those crops.

For us, knowing where coffee comes from makes the cup more meaningful.

For more on your favorite beans, check the ‘Bean Back Story’ on our product pages for a little story about the beans. 

Why Sourcing Matters with Coffee

Not all coffee supply chains work the same way.

At Philly Fair Trade Roasters, we focus on Organic and Fairtrade coffee because we believe the way coffee gets to your cup matters.

Fairtrade systems are designed to support better trading conditions and give producers more stability and opportunity.

Organic certification focuses on defined agricultural and processing standards.

Those choices also connect your morning routine to something much larger: farms, families, communities, and land thousands of miles away.  All the way to your mug; a coffee community you get to be a part of. 

Coffee or Tea: Which Should You Choose?

Choose the one you enjoy.

Seriously.

If you love tea, drink tea.

If you love coffee, we are obviously pretty excited to help you with that.

If you love both, your kitchen has room for two mugs.

Coffee may be a better fit when you want:

• More caffeine
• A bold morning drink
• Richer body
• A wide range of roast and origin flavors
• Espresso-based drinks
• A fresh-roasted daily ritual

Tea may be a better fit when you want:

• Less caffeine
• A lighter drink
• A wide variety of herbal options
• Something easy to steep
• A different afternoon or evening ritual

Frequently Asked Questions About Coffee and Tea

Is coffee healthier than tea?

Neither drink is automatically healthier for everyone. Both coffee and tea contain plant compounds that have been studied for possible health benefits. Your total diet, caffeine tolerance, preparation method, and what you add to your drink also matter.

Which has more caffeine, coffee or tea?

Coffee usually has more caffeine. An 8-ounce coffee typically has about 80–100 mg, compared with roughly 30–50 mg in an 8-ounce green or black tea. Actual amounts vary.

Can you drink coffee and tea in the same day?

Many people do. The main thing to watch is your total caffeine intake and how caffeine affects you personally, especially later in the day.

Does decaf coffee still have caffeine?

Usually, yes. Decaf coffee has much less caffeine than regular coffee, but it is generally not completely caffeine-free.

Is coffee more bitter than tea?

Not necessarily. Both can become bitter when brewed poorly. Coffee that is over-extracted may taste bitter, while tea that steeps too long can become bitter or astringent. Proper brewing helps bring out the best flavors in both.

Is coffee or tea more sustainable?

There is no simple answer. Sustainability depends on where and how a crop is grown, how farmers are treated, processing methods, transportation, packaging, and many other factors. With coffee, certifications such as Organic and Fairtrade can help shoppers find products that meet specific standards.

Final Sips: Coffee and Tea Have More in Common Than You Think

Both drinks come from plants.

Both connect us to farmers and growing regions around the world.

Both can have caffeine and naturally occurring plant compounds.

Both can create a small daily ritual worth looking forward to.

The biggest differences are where they come from, how they are processed, how they taste, how they are brewed, and how much caffeine they usually contain.

Around here, coffee will always have our heart.

We love its aroma filling the room. We love how coffees from different origins can taste completely different. And we love knowing that something as simple as your morning cup connects you with the people who grew it.

If coffee is part of your day too, we think it should be good coffee.

Organic.

Fairtrade.

Small-batch roasted.

No artificial flavors.

Just thoughtfully sourced beans roasted to help their natural flavor shine.

Ready to Make Tomorrow Morning Taste Better?

Explore our lineup of Organic, Fairtrade coffee and find a roast that fits your morning.

Whether you like something bright and lively, smooth and balanced, or dark and bold, there's a good cup waiting for you.

Shop Philly Fair Trade Roasters Coffee →

📚 Recommended Reading

Keep growing your coffee knowledge with these helpful articles:

Brewing & Coffee Education

• How to Store Coffee Beans for Maximum Freshness
• Coffee-to-Water Ratio: Brew Better Coffee Every Time
• Best Coffee Brewing Temperature Explained
• How to Make Coffee Without a Coffee Maker
• French Press Coffee Guide for Beginners

Join Our Coffee Community

Love learning about coffee?  Sign up in the footer.

Join our email newsletter for weekly brewing tips, coffee education, farmer stories, new coffee releases, and exclusive offers.

From our roaster to your morning routine—we're here to help make every cup, and every day, a little better. ☕