The Ultimate Guide to Coffee Roasts: Light, Medium, Dark and Beyond

For us coffee lovers, the roast of your coffee beans can make or break the experience. Whether you’re new to the coffee world or a long-time coffee lover, understanding how roasting changes those little green beans into a bold, aromatic cup of magic can deepen your appreciation for every sip.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take you through the spectrum of coffee roasts—from light and bright to dark and rich—exploring how roast level affects flavor, aroma, body, and even caffeine content. So grab a cup, and let’s roast!

What Is Coffee Roasting?

Roasting is the process of heating green coffee beans to bring out their aroma and flavor. The raw beans start off soft, green, and grassy-smelling. Through roasting, they undergo a series of chemical and physical changes—transforming into the fragrant, brown, crunchy beans we all recognize. Kinda like popping popcorn, though not quite as big and puffy.

Roasting is both art and science. A few seconds too long in the roaster can dramatically change the profile of the coffee.  Like making a grilled cheese sandwich; too long and too toasty, not good.  The goal? To unlock the potential of each bean—highlighting its origin, processing method, and tasting notes - while also catering to specific flavor preferences.  That’s a lot going on in those little beans.

The Coffee Roast Spectrum

Roasts fall on a spectrum from light to dark, with plenty of variation in between (check out the bean scale we have on the front of our bags to show you how light or dark a roast is). most beans can be grouped into four broad categories:

1. Light Roast
2. Medium Roast
3. Medium-Dark Roast
4. Dark Roast

Onward in our bean journey!

1. Light Coffee Roast: The Bright and Fruity Introvert

Characteristics:

• Color: Light brown
• Surface: Dry (no oils on the surface)
• Flavor: Bright, acidic, fruity, floral
• Body: Light
• Caffeine: Slightly higher than dark roasts (by mass).  This is because light roasts are roasted for less time than the dark roasts, which means the beans puff slightly less, so a 12 oz bag contains more coffee beans than a 12 oz bag of dark roasts.  Kind of like the old trick question of which weighs more, a pound of feathers or a pound of steel?  They weigh the same, just more feathers.

Light roasts preserve the origin flavors of the coffee bean—so if your beans were grown in the highlands of Ethiopia or the volcanic soils of Guatemala, you’ll taste those terroir-driven notes here.

Because the roast is stopped before the second crack (we’ll talk more about this later!), light roasts retain much of the bean’s original characteristics. Expect notes of citrus, berries, florals, and sometimes tea-like qualities. These beans often shine in manual brewing methods like pour-over where clarity of flavor is key.

Best For:

• Single-origin coffees
• Manual brewing methods (like pour overs)
• Coffee drinkers who love bright, complex flavors.  Complex in this case just means they have more flavors; not complex like putting a rocket into space.  Take the time to sip and think about the flavor notes of the coffee.  Unless you’re in a hurry in the morning; then maybe you need an instant coffee that also tastes great like this.

2. Medium Coffee Roast: The Balanced Crowd-Pleaser

Characteristics:

• Color: Medium brown
• Surface: Still dry, sometimes with a slight sheen
• Flavor: Balanced acidity and sweetness, caramel, nutty, chocolate
• Body: Medium
• Caffeine: Slightly less than light roasts (by mass)

Medium roasts are the most popular in the U.S. and many other markets. They walk the line between origin and roast flavor—retaining some fruitiness while introducing caramelization, nuttiness, and mild chocolatey notes.

The acidity is lower than in light roasts, making these coffees approachable and comforting. Medium roasts also perform well in most brewing methods—from espresso to drip.

Best For:

• Everyday coffee drinkers
• Espresso lovers who want balance
• People who enjoy a hint of fruit without too much acidity

3. Medium-Dark Coffee Roast: The Bold Bridge

Characteristics:

• Color: Rich, dark brown
• Surface: Slight oil sheen begins to appear
• Flavor: Dark chocolate, roasted nuts, spice, mild bitterness
• Body: Full-bodied
• Caffeine: Slightly lower than lighter roasts

This is where roast character starts to dominate. While some origin flavor remains, it’s increasingly complemented (and sometimes masked) by the deeper, richer notes from the roasting process. Think of this as the “bold but not burnt” category.

Often favored in traditional espresso blends, medium-dark roasts offer intensity without the smokiness of darker profiles.

Best For:

• Espresso shots with a kick
• People who like bold flavors without too much bitterness
• Milk-based drinks like lattes and cappuccinos

---

4. Dark Roast: The Deep, Smoky Classic

Characteristics:

• Color: Dark brown to nearly black
• Surface: Shiny with oils
• Flavor: Smoky, bitter, dark chocolate, toasty, sometimes ashy
• Body: Heavy
• Caffeine: Slightly lower (by mass)

Dark roasts are all about the roast flavor.  Here you'll find notes similar to dark chocolate, even smoky (a good aromatic smoky).

These roasts are created by taking the beans well past the second crack. The oils rise to the surface, contributing to that telltale sheen. While some specialty coffee enthusiasts avoid dark roasts, there's no denying their nostalgic appeal and ability to cut through milk and sugar.

Best For:

• Strong, traditional espresso
• French press brews
• Milk-heavy drinks like mochas and macchiatos
• Fans of bold, smoky flavors

Caffeine Content: Light Roast vs. Dark Roast

There’s a popular myth (not quite as popular as Bigfoot, but still a solid myth) that dark roasts have more caffeine because they taste stronger, I used to think this too! In reality, light roasts have slightly more caffeine by mass, but dark roasts are less dense, so you might scoop more volume into your brew. It all depends on how you're measuring your coffee—by weight or by volume.  Remember our feather and steel analogy from earlier.

Here's the breakdown:

• By weight (grams): Light roast has slightly more caffeine
• By volume (scoops): Dark roast might deliver more caffeine, because the beans are lighter and puffier.  Greens beans lose moisture and expand when roasted, like popping popcorn. 

Flavor Development: The Coffee Roasting Process

So what’s actually happening during the roast (follow us on Instagram or Facebook to see vids of some of the below processes in action!) -

1. Drying Phase: Moisture evaporates from the green beans.  Green beans can lose approx. 20% of their weight (from moisture) during the roasting process.
2. Maillard Reaction: Sugars and amino acids react to create browning and complex flavor development (think toast or roasted nuts).
3. First Crack: A popping sound signals that the beans are expanding and beginning to caramelize. This is when light roasts are usually dropped.  See, told you we’d come back to talking about the first crack!
4. Development Time: Roasters can manipulate the time after first crack to bring out sweetness or brightness.
5. Second Crack: Beans pop again. Oils start to migrate to the surface. Medium-dark to dark roasts occur here.
6. Dark Roast Zone: Extended roasting.

Bonus Fun Fact – did you know we have a large TV screen in the shop that can be used to watch the temperature and trend lines of the roast as the beans are roasting?

Choosing the Right Coffee Roast for You

Not sure which roast you prefer, try them all!  Here’s a quick guide to help you explore:

Also consider your brew method. Light roasts are best for manual brewing (think pour over and similar) while medium and dark roasts are great for espresso, drip, or French press.

Regional Coffee Roast Preferences Around the World

Coffee roast preferences are cultural. Check out our selections online and let your coffee mug be your passport!  Here's a quick snapshot:

• United States: Medium to medium-dark dominates, though light roast is growing among specialty drinkers.
• Italy: Dark roast rules, especially for espresso.
• Scandinavia: Very light roasts are popular; these countries are known for bright, acidic coffees.
• France: Deep, smoky dark roasts are preferred.
• Latin America: Medium roasts are common, especially for traditional drip coffee.

Final Sips: Roast Isn’t About Better or Worse—It’s About Preference

The world of coffee roasts is rich and complex. Whether you love a citrusy Ethiopian light roast or a deep, smoky French roast, the best roast is the one you enjoy most.

Experiment. Explore. Taste widely. Your coffee journey is personal—and knowing your roast preference is just the beginning.

Quick Roast Recap:

Have a favorite roast? Get in touch with us, we’d love to hear more!